Is Pet Insurance Actually Worth Cost? Look at the Pros and Cons

When John and Sarah adopted their rambunctious Labrador Retriever puppy named Buddy, they wanted to make sure they could provide him with the best care possible. At his first vet visit, the vet recommended looking into pet insurance to help cover any unexpected illnesses or injuries Buddy might experience as he grew up. John and Sarah were skeptical at first, wondering if pet insurance was really necessary or worth the monthly expense.

A year later, Buddy tore his ACL while playing fetch at the park. The surgery and physical therapy to repair his knee cost over $5,000. Thankfully, John and Sarah had purchased pet insurance which covered 90% of Buddy’s treatment after their deductible. They were grateful they had pet insurance to significantly reduce the financial burden of Buddy’s injury. However, one of their friends had skipped pet insurance and was now regretting that decision after facing a similar large vet bill.

John and Sarah were glad they opted for pet insurance given Buddy’s experience. But they understood their friend’s hesitation about whether pet insurance is really worth the cost. In truth, there are pros and cons to pet insurance and its value depends on your individual circumstances.

What is Pet Insurance?

Pet insurance is a type of insurance policy that helps pet owners cover the costs of veterinary care for their pets. It works similarly to health insurance for humans in that it helps pay for medical expenses related to illness, injuries, accidents, and routine preventive care like vaccinations and checkups.

Pet insurance plans cover a portion of these costs, typically 70-90%, after the policy holder pays a deductible. This can provide significant financial relief for pet owners facing large unexpected veterinary bills. Most pet insurance plans allow you to customize aspects like annual limits, deductibles, and reimbursement percentages.

Pet insurance covers expenses related to accidents and illnesses, including conditions that develop over time like cancer or diabetes. It also often covers prescription medications, dental cleanings, MRI/CT scans, surgery, hospitalization, and more. Wellness plans and routine care riders can provide coverage for preventive services too.

To get coverage, pet owners pay a monthly premium. When they incur a vet bill, they submit a claim to get reimbursed for the agreed upon portion after their deductible. This makes pet insurance plans similar to filing health insurance claims for humans. Grow Glide

The goal of pet insurance is to help pet owners budget for the healthcare costs of their furry family members. It provides peace of mind against the financial burden of an emergency vet visit or serious pet illness. While it doesn’t cover 100% of costs, it makes vet care more affordable.

Pros of Pet Insurance

Pet insurance can provide valuable financial protection against unexpected veterinary costs. Some of the key benefits of pet insurance include:

• Covers Unexpected Vet Costs: One of the biggest advantages of pet insurance is that it can cover expensive veterinary bills in the event your pet has an accident, injury, or illness that requires treatment. This provides peace of mind if your pet needs emergency care, surgery, hospitalization, or other costly procedures.

• Preventative Care: Many pet insurance plans help cover routine preventative care like annual exams, vaccinations, heartworm testing, and dental cleanings. This makes it more affordable to maintain your pet’s health.

• Hereditary Conditions: Pet insurance often covers congenital and hereditary conditions like hip dysplasia, hereditary cataracts, or luxating patellas. These conditions can be expensive to treat, so having coverage provides financial protection.

• Chronic Conditions: If your pet develops an ongoing health issue like diabetes, allergies, arthritis, or cancer, pet insurance can help cover treatment over the long-term. This includes medication and testing costs.

• Alternative Therapies: Some pet insurance plans cover alternative treatments like acupuncture, hydrotherapy, chiropractic care, and rehabilitation therapy if recommended by your vet.

• Wellness Rewards: Certain providers offer wellness rewards programs that reimburse you for preventative care expenses like vaccines, flea/tick/heartworm prevention, and routine office visits.

• Customizable: You can often customize your pet insurance plan based on your budget, needs, and the level of coverage you want. This allows you to find an optimal plan.

Having pet insurance can provide invaluable financial security against high vet bills. For pet parents, the peace of mind of knowing you can afford any care your pet needs is a major benefit.

Cons of Pet Insurance

Pet insurance can have some drawbacks to consider before signing up. The main potential downsides include:

Monthly Premiums – Pet insurance plans require paying a monthly or annual premium, which can get expensive depending on the type and level of coverage. Premiums often increase as your pet ages due to higher risk of illness.

Deductibles – Most pet insurance plans have an annual deductible ranging from $100 to $1000 per condition. You must pay out-of-pocket for treatment costs until meeting the deductible. Some have per-incident deductibles.

Coverage Limits – Insurers limit the maximum annual or lifetime amount they’ll reimburse per condition or overall. Limits often range from $5,000 to $20,000. Once reaching the limit, you pay the remaining costs.

Pre-Existing Conditions – Pet insurance providers do not cover pre-existing conditions. This includes any illness or injury your pet had before enrollment or during a waiting period after signing up.

Reimbursement Delays – You must pay your vet first and get reimbursed later. Reimbursement can take 2-6 weeks depending on the insurer.

Limited Providers – Some insurers restrict which vets you can use or reimburse lower amounts for non-network vets.

Exclusions – Many conditions, tests, and procedures are excluded from coverage, like preventive care and elective procedures. Exclusions vary greatly between providers.

Policy Cancellations – Insurers can cancel your policy if you miss payments or make too many claims. This leaves your pet uninsured if conditions develop later.

Find More valuable Content On: Revolve Loan 

Types of Pet Insurance Plans

There are a few main types of pet insurance plans to consider:

Accident Only

Accident-only pet insurance covers veterinary costs related to injuries from accidents, such as broken bones, bites, or getting hit by a car. It does not cover illnesses. This type of plan generally has lower premiums but less coverage. It can be a good option for pet owners on a tight budget or who have a pet with a low risk of illness.

Comprehensive

Comprehensive pet insurance provides more extensive coverage for both accidents and illnesses, including cancer, diabetes, digestive issues, hereditary conditions, and more. Premiums are higher, but you get reimbursement for more veterinary expenses. Comprehensive plans often have a deductible and co-insurance.

Maximum Benefit

With maximum benefit pet insurance, there is a set limit or cap on the total amount the policy will pay out over the lifetime of your pet. Once you hit that maximum, coverage will stop. This allows you to set a policy with premiums you can afford, but the total payout is limited. Maximum benefit plans can be paired with accident only or comprehensive coverage.

The type of coverage that is right for you depends on your budget, your pet’s breed and age, and what risks you want to cover. Work with a pet insurance provider to select the optimal plan type and coverage limits.

Average Cost of Pet Insurance

The average cost of pet insurance varies significantly based on the type of pet, breed, age, location, policy limits, and deductibles. Some key factors that influence pet insurance premiums include:

• Type of Pet: Insurance for dogs is more expensive than cats on average. Dogs are more prone to injuries and illnesses that require expensive treatments. Average monthly costs for dog insurance range from $30-$70, while cat insurance averages $15-$40 per month.

• Breed: Some breeds are predisposed to certain hereditary conditions, making their insurance cost more. For example, English and French bulldogs often require coverage for breathing issues and hip dysplasia. Their premiums range from $80-$120 monthly. Mixed breeds with lower risks have lower premiums.

• Age: Like human health insurance, pet insurance costs more for older pets due to higher risks. Average monthly premiums for puppies and kittens start around $20, then increase to $30-$50 for middle-aged pets. Seniors over age 10 have the highest premiums, from $60-$100 on average.

• Location: The cost of vet care varies by region, driving insurance costs up in higher-cost areas. Average monthly premiums range from $25-$50 in lower-cost Midwest states to $40-$100 in higher-cost coastal states.

• Policy Limits: Policies with higher annual or per-condition limits have higher premiums. Average limits run from $5,000 to unlimited annually, and $2,000 to $10,000 per condition. Higher limits mean higher monthly costs.

• Deductibles: Policies with lower deductibles have higher premiums. Average annual deductibles run from $100 to $1,000. Choosing a higher deductible lowers the monthly premium.

So in summary, pet insurance costs vary widely based on many factors. On average, expect to pay $30-$70 monthly for dogs and $15-$40 for cats with mid-range coverage limits and deductibles. Compare multiple providers to find the optimal balance of premiums, coverage, and deductibles for your pet’s needs and budget. Grow Glide

Factors that Affect Cost

The cost of pet insurance can vary significantly depending on several key factors:

Type of Pet

Insurance premiums are generally higher for dogs than cats. This is because dogs tend to require more veterinary care over their lifetime. Within each type of pet, costs can also vary by breed.

Age

Younger pets are cheaper to insure than older pets. Most pet insurance companies do not insure pets over a certain age, usually around 8-10 years old. As pets get older, they are more prone to illnesses and injuries which increases their risk profile.

Breed

Some dog and cat breeds are predisposed to certain genetic conditions and illnesses. These breeds will have higher premiums. For example, Labrador Retrievers are prone to hip and elbow dysplasia which can require expensive treatments.

Location

The cost of veterinary care can vary significantly by geographic region. Areas with higher costs of living and more advanced veterinary care will also have higher pet insurance premiums. Urban areas also tend to have higher premiums than rural areas.

Top Pet Insurance Providers

Pet insurance is offered by a number of companies that provide various types of plans and coverage options. Here’s an overview of some of the top pet insurance providers:

Healthy Paws

• One of the top-rated pet insurance companies with excellent customer service
• Offers customizable annual limits and deductibles
• Covers hereditary and congenital conditions
• Quick and easy claims process with reimbursements in under 2 weeks

ASPCA

• Backed and endorsed by the American Society for the Prevention of Cruelty to Animals
• Covers wellness care including exams, vaccinations, and flea/heartworm prevention
• Offers unlimited annual benefits with no caps on payouts
• Available to all pets regardless of breed or age

Nationwide

• Provides a wide range of plan options including accident-only and wellness add-ons
• Covers alternative therapies like acupuncture and hydrotherapy
• VetHelpline service provides 24/7 access to veterinary professionals
• Policyholders can choose any licensed vet nationwide

Trupanion

• Pays vets directly so owners don’t have to pay upfront costs
• Covers 90% of actual vet bills with no payout limits
• Policyholders can change coverage levels at any time
• Available in the US, Canada, and Australia

These leading pet insurers offer a range of coverage options to meet different needs and budgets. Comparing plans, costs, exclusions, and customer service can help choose the best provider for your pet.

Is Pet Insurance Worth It?

Deciding if pet insurance is worth it involves carefully weighing the pros and cons and analyzing the costs. Here are some key considerations:

Pros of having pet insurance:

• Covers expensive vet bills for injuries, illnesses, surgery. This is the main benefit, as veterinary care costs have been rising.

• Provides peace of mind knowing you have financial assistance for pet medical needs. Reduces stress of facing large surprise bills.

• Allows you to budget monthly premiums rather than large lump sums. Makes costs more predictable.

• Covers hereditary and chronic conditions once policy waiting period is met.

• Some plans cover preventative care like vaccinations and dental cleanings.

Cons of pet insurance:

• Monthly premiums are an added expense ranging $30-$100 on average per pet. Higher for comprehensive plans.

• Pre-existing conditions are usually not covered. Many have a waiting period before coverage kicks in.

• Reimbursements can take time to process. You often still need to pay vet costs upfront.

• Not all plans cover wellness services like checkups. These are an add-on.

• Insurers may increase premiums over the pet’s lifetime, reducing cost-effectiveness.

Key takeaways:

For pets with chronic illness or those prone to injury, insurance can be worth it despite the costs. For healthy pets, it’s more of a personal choice depending on your finances and risk tolerance. Get quotes, read policies closely, and choose a plan that fits your needs. While not right for everyone, for many pet owners the benefits outweigh the expense.

Conclusions

In summary, pet insurance can provide peace of mind and financial protection against unexpected veterinary costs for your furry companions. However, it is not necessarily right for every pet owner.

The main benefits of pet insurance are that it can cover large vet bills for injuries, illnesses, and other medical issues that would otherwise be very expensive out-of-pocket. This allows pet owners to budget for a monthly premium versus risking massive bills. Pet insurance also allows owners to get their pets the best care possible without finances dictating treatment options.

On the downside, pet insurance does have monthly or annual costs that some owners may not want to take on. There are also many exclusions, limitations, deductibles, and waiting periods to be aware of. Pet owners will still likely have some out-of-pocket costs even with coverage. Additionally, the reimbursement process can be time consuming.

When deciding if pet insurance is worth it, owners should consider factors like their pet’s breed, age, pre-existing conditions, and overall health. Higher risk pets generally benefit more from coverage. Owners should also consider costs versus their own budget and savings. For owners who would struggle to cover a large vet bill out-of-pocket, insurance is likely worth considering.

Ultimately there is no one-size-fits all recommendation. Pet owners need to weigh the pros, cons, and costs based on their specific situation. But pet insurance can provide valuable protection against financial surprises and allow pets to get great care when they need it most.